|
I had the same results with both.The case goes back to Amazon. The first was a Samsung HD103UJ, 1000GB/7200rpm/32M. I experienced the same result as S. Feld (timerider), who also rated the case with one star.I tried two different HDD. The second was a Western Digital WD10EADS, 1000GB/SATA/32M, which just arrived from Amazon.
One review said a 1TB drive was used. Everything I read about this enclosure sounds good, but I don't understand this specification: "Up to 750 GB 3.5-inch SATA hard disk drive". Why do the specs limit the size of drive.
I highly recommend this item to anyone that needs a enclosure. The Antec MX-1 comes with all needed hardware even a e-sata cable is included. The external look of the drive is very pleasing aswell. I have only had WD (Western Digital) external HDD that use passive cooling that has seem to work fine until my 320GB WD My Book Premium stop working one day. The Antec MX-1 is ultra quiet to use an active cooling system (fan to blow air). The nice Blue LED indicator light reflects off the surface the enclosure is resting on if it is horizontal.
A vertical holder comes with the enclosure if a vertical position is desired. The HDD did not click or hum unusually, but would not be recognized by the computer any longer. The HDD spun up and has been working fine since. The aluminum body is well made and the HDD is nicely cushioned by internal vibration damping material. I bought this enclosure to give my 320GB WD external HDD a new home. I bought this enclosure not sure if I needed or wanted to spend the extra money for the cooling system provided with this enclosure.
I gutted the 320GB My Book Premium and inserted the 320GB HDD into the Antec MX-1, voila, it recognized it instantly. I have another 320GB WD My Book that uses passive cooling (no fan for cooling) that is actually louder than the Antec MX-1 when it spins up which indicates to me that the Antec MX-1 External HDD Enclosure is very well made and utilizes the dampening material perfectly.
I chose Antec because it's the same brand as my PC case. No problems.
It came out before larger drives were common so the product description only mentions 750GB. All cables are included - eSATA and USB.
My motherboard already had an eSATA jack so I didn't need to install the included interface. According to Antec's web site, this enclosure can handle 1TB drives.
This is the first time I've purchased a hard drive enclosure. It only took me about 10 minutes to install my old Seagate 720GB drive to this case.
FYI - The product description on Amazon needs to be updated.
But it isn't perfect:1) It's a bit noisy when it is on. And it has no problem with the 1.5TB drive I installed in it. There are a lot of very small screws and many of them are a pain to get back in (especially when you have big fingers like I do). The disk enclosure is exactly as advertised. It works well and is instantly recognized by XP and Vista computers. It has a fan and that keeps the unit cool but in a quiet room, the fan seems to be really noisy.2) It's a bit of a pain to install the disk.
|
